Asslaam Alaikumm
Today By chance I was suffering nawasib's blog, I come up with lot of tadlees and arguments with dhaefs narrations
let me share one of them how effendi mislead people
he made a post Allah descends? and mention a narration
he writes:
Zaid on authority of Abdullah Bin Sinaan who said, I heard Abu Abdullah (as) saying: On the day of Arafa, Allah descends at noon to earth on a she-camel whose thigh reaches (sorrounds) the people of Arafa from right to left.
http://gift2shias.com/2011/02/04/allah-descends/
the hadith is here
يد عن عبد الله بن سنان قال سمعت ابا عبد الله (ع) يقول ان الله ينزل في يوم عرفة في اول الزوال إلى الارض على جمل افرق يصال بفخديه اهل عرفات يمينا وشمالا ولا يزال كذلك حتى إذا كان عند المغرب ونفر الناس وكل الله ملكين بجبال المازمين يناديان عند المضيق الذي رأيت يا رب سلم سلم والرب يصعد إلى السماء ويقول جل جلاله امين امين يا رب العالمين فلذلك لاتكاد ترى صريعا ولاكسيرا
http://www.rafed.net/books/hadith/usul-16/04.html
the chain of the narration is not relliable
There is great jarah on the زيد النرسي by al-Khoi ,Sheikh Gazeri and Sheikh Asif Mohsini
The Narration was taken from the Book of Zaid al-Na'rsi which is not Reliable according to Sayed al-Khu'i and some other scholors
see more here
http://www.alkhoei.com/arabic/pages/book.php?bcc=1210&itg=21&bi=182&s=ct
http://www.al-khoei.us/books/index.php?id=7381
Today By chance I was suffering nawasib's blog, I come up with lot of tadlees and arguments with dhaefs narrations
let me share one of them how effendi mislead people
he made a post Allah descends? and mention a narration
he writes:
Zaid on authority of Abdullah Bin Sinaan who said, I heard Abu Abdullah (as) saying: On the day of Arafa, Allah descends at noon to earth on a she-camel whose thigh reaches (sorrounds) the people of Arafa from right to left.
http://gift2shias.com/2011/02/04/allah-descends/
the hadith is here
يد عن عبد الله بن سنان قال سمعت ابا عبد الله (ع) يقول ان الله ينزل في يوم عرفة في اول الزوال إلى الارض على جمل افرق يصال بفخديه اهل عرفات يمينا وشمالا ولا يزال كذلك حتى إذا كان عند المغرب ونفر الناس وكل الله ملكين بجبال المازمين يناديان عند المضيق الذي رأيت يا رب سلم سلم والرب يصعد إلى السماء ويقول جل جلاله امين امين يا رب العالمين فلذلك لاتكاد ترى صريعا ولاكسيرا
http://www.rafed.net/books/hadith/usul-16/04.html
the chain of the narration is not relliable
There is great jarah on the زيد النرسي by al-Khoi ,Sheikh Gazeri and Sheikh Asif Mohsini
The Narration was taken from the Book of Zaid al-Na'rsi which is not Reliable according to Sayed al-Khu'i and some other scholors
see more here
http://www.alkhoei.com/arabic/pages/book.php?bcc=1210&itg=21&bi=182&s=ct
http://www.al-khoei.us/books/index.php?id=7381
No comments:
Post a Comment