Investigation and Probation of a chain-less Hadith Kudsi.

Investigation and Probation of a chain-less Hadith Kudsi.

There are also some narrations and Ahadiths which are famous and common among people. One of those is Hadith Kudsi which is very famous among people even people have started its advertisement campaigns with full swing and This Hadith is also pasted regularly in Mosques (Masajids) and different public places .Utmost pity on those Ulemas who narrate these unauthentic and fabricated ahadeeth on pulpits.الأمان و الحفیظ

Among ancient Scholars Hakeem Tirmizi was first to quote this chain-less hadeeth therefore the basic origin and first source of this hadith is the book of Hakeem Tirmizi i.e. Nawadur al-Usool (نوادر الأصول)

Hakeem Tirmizi quote:

قَال الله تعالَى لداود علَيه السلَام تريد وأريد ويكون ما أريد فَإذا أردت ما أريد كفيتك ما تريد ويكون ما أريد وإذا أردت غير ما أريد عنيتك فيما تريد ويكون ما أُريد

ALLAH Almighty said to Hazrat Dawood (David) O my servant ! One is Your wish and one is Mine.If you sacrifice your wish over my wish then I will conserve you in your wish and only that will happen which I will want and If you will not sacrifice your wish over My wish then I will make you tired in your wish and only that will happen which I will want.

Nawadar al-Usool Al hakeem al-Tirmzi Vol  2 Page 107 Publisher Daar al-Jaleel Beirut.

In addition to this, this Hadith Kudsi has been quoted with no chain in following secondary sources

Almarqa fi Sharah al-Mishkaat (Allama Ali Alqari al-Hanfi)

Tafsir Rooh al-Bayan (Ismael Haqi bin Mustafi al-Istanboli - al-Hanfi)

Qowat al-Qaloob fi Mamla't al-Mehboob (Muhammad bin Ali bin Atya al-Harsi)

Hashia al-Saawi Ali al-Sharah al-Sagheer(Abi al-Abass Ahmad bin Muhammad al-Khalooti)

Ihya al-Uloom al-Deen (Abu Hamid Muhammad bin Muhammad al-Ghazali al-Toosi)

''Nawadar al-Usool'' is the most ancient book among those in which this hadith kudsi has been narrated . In later books this Hadith has been narrated from this book.

Book ''Nawaadar al-Usool'' is the compilation of Hakeem Tirmizi. Some people may become doubtful due to the name of Hakeem Tirmizi i.e. By Hakeem Tirmizi It means Hakeem Tirmizi whose famous book Sunan Tirmizi is included in Sihah Sitta but it should be clear that these two personalities are different.The name of prominent Muhadith is Abu Eesa Muhammad bin Eesa al-Tirmizi and name of Hakeem Tirmizi is Aboo Abdullah Muhammad bin Ali bin al-Hassan al-Hakeem al-Tirmizi .

This Hadith Kudsi seems to be fabricated apparently because no chain is included in the above mentioned books in which this Hadith is narrated. From this it is at least proved that this Hadith Kudsi has no credential therefore it is mandatory to refrain from narrating and stating this Hadith until its authentic chain is not known and is necessary so that the stage of lying upon ALLAH and his Prophet (asws) may not reach because lying upon ALLAH and His prophet (saw) is forbidden and a greater sin.

Wa’ Salam

 Researched by Ismael Deobandi and Translated by Imamia Revealing the Truth